Table finish

Our table has all its parts in place.  Isn't it wonderful?  I can't wait for all the special meals, holidays and celebrations that this table will play a part in.  To have my whole family around one table is going to be amazing.  If I could, I'd plop that baby right in place today.

But alas:

So it will squat in the living room a while longer.  

So now my dilemma is over how to finish it.  Should I go with a weathered, antique finish like our lovely model?

Or this Irish antique?

Or should we go with a darker (but still old-looking) finish?  Thusly:

These are the chairs and chandelier (minus the shades) that will be going in the dining room.

I will ponder this perplexing puzzle and post PDQ.